Testimonials

Linda Ankrom gave McCartan Insurance Group Inc. a 5 STAR RATING

Ryan and the people at the McCartan Insurance Group have taken care of our home and auto coverage for the last 14 years. They have always been quick to respond to our questions and concerns. They are excellent representatives of the Nationwide brand.

Fast & friendly & knowledgeable

We were in the process of buying a new house and wanted new insurance because we were unhappy with our previous provider. We needed to get switched over in a short amount of time and a family member recommended McCartan Insurance Group so I called late on a Friday afternoon thinking I was going to get an answering service but Joel answered and asked me for some info and got me a quote by Sunday! I had a lot of questions and Joel was super responsive and so patient with me on every single phone call (and I called A LOT!). Not once did he ever make me feel like I was asking any dumb questions. He was very knowledgeable and helped me figure out all the different options for our home. Not only do they offer great rates but the customer service so far has been exceptional. I highly recommend them!

Joel and his team are fantastic. I have receive emails at 6pm and will find an email waiting for me in the morning when we bought our new car. Joel followed through and made sure we had the correct coverage with buying a new 2020. My wife and I appreciate Joel and his team!

We have always received great service from the team at McCartan Insurance Group. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and quick to respond to any questions or claims we have or to make any updates to policies we need!!!

Great ideas, great options, great execution. A cut above

Joel McCartan and team have been fantastic to work with over the years! They are always very responsive and go the extra mile for our family. They have also been extremely helpful when we’ve had to file claims. I would recommend Joel and his team to anyone!

Joel has been great to work with. Answering all my questions very timely and helpful to find the best [insurance] options for me and my family.

Our insurance agent has made sure we have the right coverage for our home and auto insurance. When we had a claim after hail damage to our roof everything was handled quickly and professionally. It has been a very positive experience working with them.